Archive | Common Core

We Need a Real Debate About Common Core

By: Dr. Laurence Peters

Few can be puzzled why a group of southern states, most notably Oklahoma, South Carolina and Louisiana are rejecting the Common Core. As Dave Powell writes in Education Week, all three states, “rank close to the bottom of all states on the Education Week Research Center’s 2014 K12 Achievement Index, which takes into account National Assessment of Educational Progress, or NAEP, scores? Advanced Placement scores? and high school graduation rates.”

What politicians in these states are clearly afraid of is the distinct probability that they would continue to fall to the bottom of any new national tests such as contemplated by the Common Core and then be faced with public pressure to spend more than they do (certainly as much on a per capita basis as their northern counterparts) to improve. But they are split personalities they want on the one hand the national kudos that comes from being identified as a progressive governor who supports well regarded movements as Common Core (and the federal dollars that accompanied adoption) on the other they want to stay popular with their core supporters, particularly, if like Jindal, they are considering running for national office. So when instead of engaging in reasoned argument they frequently fall back on demagoguery. And so a bellwether Republican Governor wanting out of Common Core talks about federal overreach even as he asks voters to ignore the fact that he took $17 million from Race to the Top funds when he joined the testing consortium known as the PARCC consortium. But somehow something happened after he banked the money to move him to change his mind and to send him into fits of hyperbolic rage as he suddenly realizes that “The federal government has hijacked and destroyed the Common Core initiative,” the initiative that was fine a year ago “now becomes the latest effort by big government disciples to strip away state rights and put Washington, D.C., in control of everything.” How come? He does not explain. Meanwhile Louisiana continues to reduce education spending and is now, according to the Center for Budget Priorities among 35 states that have cut funding per student for the 201314school year than before the recession”

We are all worse off when politicians refuse to acknowledge the many factors that go into producing a high quality education system and instead pander to their base. For example, politicians like Gov. Nikki Haley of South Carolina talks about the need for “finding South Carolina solutions to South Carolina challenges” as a reason to reject Common Core. Clearly like Jindal, she feels no embarrassment in waving the states rights flag, but is that all she has to offer? There are some valid reasons to be opposed to common core but mostly these do not poll as well as the states rights issues and so we tend not to hear about them. For example, a number of issues have to do with the poor implementation related to the fact that while hundreds of millions of dollars from the federal government have gone into development of a whole generation of sophisticated tests, states are left to scramble for dollars to pay for the enormous professional development costs Common Core adoption entails. We as educators need to encourage our communities to ask more searching questions about the reform initiatives and reject the media enabled punch and judy show that too often substitutes for serious debate.


Join The Discussion: Common Core

Background: The Washington Post (see link below) recently described how the new Common Core Standards for K-12 schools came to be adopted in 43 states.  Financed largely by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Common Core is a set of uniform academic standards in English and math replacing the  uneven patchwork quilt that left the standards up to each state. Proponents say Common Core will better prepare students for success in college and career and opponents says education policy should be left to state and local governments. Read more here:

Do you support the Common Core Initiative?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Do you think teachers have had adequate preparation to teach the new standards?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...


Common Core has students writing — on just about every subject

BELLE CHASSE, La. — In the early elementary school grades, Zachary Davis and his classmates at Belle Chasse Primary School in suburban New Orleans wrote almost entirely from personal experience: describing their ideal vacation, trying to convince readers that a longer school year would be a good (or bad) idea, penning a letter about their adventures during summer break.

That all changed this school year.

As a fourth-grader, Zachary more rarely writes stories or essays based solely on his experience or imaginative musings anymore. Instead, it’s all about citing “textual evidence.”

“In third grade they would just ask us to, like, describe your dream store. It was easy to me,” said Zachary, adding that he enjoys the new challenge.

(Read More)