There is great news from California. The State Board of Education has announced that it will drop its longstanding textbook adoption standards, which for many years have only allowed California schools to use state textbook funds on a limited set of choices. Many states have approved lists of textbooks, but California was relatively unique in limiting options to a very short list. For example, in recent years, California allowed only two basal reading series, Open Court and Houghton Mifflin.
For many years, California and the other large textbook adoption state, Texas, have had an outsized impact on textbooks everywhere, because publishers have had to dance to their tune. This has had a negative effect nationally. It has restricted innovation, and kept smaller competitors out of the textbook market, since it is hugely expensive to go through the adoption process.
For an advocate of evidence-based reform, the California and Texas textbook adoption policies are particularly galling. While California had rules against mentioning junk food in texts, for example, no textbook adoption state has ever paid any attention to the evidence base supporting the use of particular texts. This meant that in California, districts could use their textbook funds on texts found in high-quality research to be ineffective, or ones that had never been evaluated, while programs with strong evidence of effectiveness were effectively banned from the state.
- Slavin: Overcoming Four Barriers to Evidence-Based Education - May 6, 2013
- Sputnik: Taking the guesswork out of policy - January 15, 2013
- Sputnik: Effect size matters in educational research - January 9, 2013
- Sputnik: Technology without supports – like cotton candy for breakfast - January 4, 2013
- Sputnik: Transforming Low-Performing Schools - December 13, 2012
- Sputnik: - November 12, 2012
- Sputnik: It’s the Right Time to do the Right Thing - November 2, 2012
- Sputnik: Sunset for Textbook Adoption in California - November 2, 2012
- Sputnik: What the Presidential Election means for Evidenced-based reform - October 25, 2012
- Sputnik: Won’t Back Down – Union-bashing goes Hollywood - October 12, 2012